The Stem Cell Debate.

This link will take you to ongoing debates and discussions on several topics of interest to members of Sensitize ©. All members of Sensitize © are welcome to start new debates and discussions.

Moderator: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh

Post Reply

Are you in favour to Stem Cell Research and if so, why?

Yes and my reasons are posted to this debate thread.
1
50%
No and my reasons are posted to this debate thread.
1
50%
 
Total votes: 2

User avatar
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
site owner, media producer & writer
Posts: 2185
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 7:32 am
Location: Derry, Ireland
Contact:

The Stem Cell Debate.

Post by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh »

I frequently visit and interact on the Mark Thomas Info forum. Today one of their other regulars and someone I have a lot of time for, Deacon, posted the following three links. I have posted my response to them below in this message but I would really like to hear other member's opinions on this topic.
Originally posted by deacon on the Mark Thomas Info Forum wrote: Micheal J Fox stem cell ad

Rush Limbaugh "acting" like Michael J. Fox

Micheal J Fox interview
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
Administrator, editor & owner of the Sensitize © online community of forums and domain for artists, e-poets, filmmakers, media/music producers and writers working through here. To buy the Kindle book of Illustrated Poetry, Sensitize © - Volume One / Poems that could be Films if they were Funded by myself with illustrations by Welsh filmmaker and graphic artist; Norris Nuvo click here for N. Ireland and UK sales. If purchasing in the U.S.A. or internationally then please click here.

ASIN B00L1RS0UI

My writing is not covered by Creative Commons policy and may not be republished without permission. All rights reserved. All Sensitize © Arts sponsorship donations and postal inquiries to:

Louis P. Burns
42 Farland Way
DERRY
N. Ireland.
BT48 0RS
Telephone (UK): 028 71219225


Click here to Join Sensitize © Arts via Facebook or to contact the site owner: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh with any forum hosting or site related inquiries.
User avatar
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
site owner, media producer & writer
Posts: 2185
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 7:32 am
Location: Derry, Ireland
Contact:

Post by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh »

The advert and interview with Micheal J. Fox are heartbreaking to watch. He is alive, so any notions of pro-lifers being opposed to keeping someone alive is completely insane in my opinion and against their own agendas, political or spiritual.

Fox states that the stem cells he's campaigning to have used to treat his condition are going to be destroyed anyway, so where is the problem?

Rush Limbaugh should be smacked across the back of his neck with a heavy blunt instrument and left up a dark, unused road, preferably on a rainy night. If 'it' manages to crawl to a clear space, maybe 'it' can get assistance from paramedics and the police. It would be something quite wonderful if 'it' needed controversial treatment to mend 'its' injuries. 'It's' a stain on humanity...
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
Administrator, editor & owner of the Sensitize © online community of forums and domain for artists, e-poets, filmmakers, media/music producers and writers working through here. To buy the Kindle book of Illustrated Poetry, Sensitize © - Volume One / Poems that could be Films if they were Funded by myself with illustrations by Welsh filmmaker and graphic artist; Norris Nuvo click here for N. Ireland and UK sales. If purchasing in the U.S.A. or internationally then please click here.

ASIN B00L1RS0UI

My writing is not covered by Creative Commons policy and may not be republished without permission. All rights reserved. All Sensitize © Arts sponsorship donations and postal inquiries to:

Louis P. Burns
42 Farland Way
DERRY
N. Ireland.
BT48 0RS
Telephone (UK): 028 71219225


Click here to Join Sensitize © Arts via Facebook or to contact the site owner: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh with any forum hosting or site related inquiries.
User avatar
Catherine Edmunds
artist, poet & writer
Posts: 428
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 8:05 pm
Location: north east england
Contact:

Post by Catherine Edmunds »

Rush Limbaugh is a disgusting human being.

Michael J Fox talks sense, and has dignity.

There is a difficulty, in my mind, however. Fox states that these embryos that scientists want to be used for research would be destroyed anyway, so why not use them for something useful? Seems reasonable, until you ask why there are embryos available in the first place. The answer is to help infertile couples, of course, but that begs the question... is it ethical to help them in this way if it means producing all these 'surplus' embryos which will then be killed? A huge number of these infertile couples only need this treatment because they've been so busy with their careers that they've left it too late to conceive naturally. That sort of selfishness is then rewared with this treatment, with 'surplus' embryos being the unfortunate victims.

I find the concept of deliberately killing an embryo deeply upsetting.

It's true that most embryos, when conceived naturally, do die anyway. Only a few go on to implant and then go to a full term pregnancy. So does it matter?

I'm going to have to sit on the fence for a while over this one.

In the meantime, I think it imperative that the scientists get cracking on adult stem cell research. The huge advantage this has, is that the patient's own stem cells can be used in any treatment, thus getting rid of the danger of rejection. The disadvantage is that embryo stem cells are much easier to multiply, and you would need large numbers for any sort of treatment.

It's a difficult one. Adult stem cells yes; embryo ones? Very, very hard question. If science has created these embryos, it has an ethical duty towards them, in my view, that doesn't include either throwing them away or 'using' them in any way other than to implant them in a woman's womb to give them the chance of life.
spacecadet
visitor

Post by spacecadet »

I think all the heretics involved in stem cell research should be burnt at the stake as Alzeimers is a punishment from God. I also drink my own ****.

Sorry, this really isn't my point of view but due to a sticky mouse I voted for the wrong thing and thought I should try to defend my "corner".

The reality is that once again Lugh has failed to put a "Yes and No" button on poll. In future could you please put three buttons on these things. One called "YES", one called "NO" and another one in the middle called "DAVE". I'm afraid that's normally how I want to vote. On the one hand anyone who messes with the jigsaw puzzle that God created should burn in eternal hell, on the other hand anyone who stops such research should be beaten to death (with cricket bats) by the parents of the children who die because the cures to their genetic ills are to be reached through this research.

So this poll is a no brainer for me. I vote "DAVE".
spacecadet
visitor

Post by spacecadet »

Should mention that despite being a proddy I'm a very strong Pro-Lifer and all that entails. I only have to look into the eyes of my children to see God.
User avatar
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
site owner, media producer & writer
Posts: 2185
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 7:32 am
Location: Derry, Ireland
Contact:

Post by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh »

delph_ambi wrote: Rush Limbaugh is a disgusting human being.
Human being?
delph_ambi wrote: Michael J Fox talks sense, and has dignity.
Funny, I never liked him as an actor, but fair play to him for fighting his corner. He's a brilliant and honest activist.
delph_ambi wrote: There is a difficulty, in my mind, however. Fox states that these embryos that scientists want to be used for research would be destroyed anyway, so why not use them for something useful? Seems reasonable, until you ask why there are embryos available in the first place. The answer is to help infertile couples, of course, but that begs the question... is it ethical to help them in this way if it means producing all these 'surplus' embryos which will then be killed? A huge number of these infertile couples only need this treatment because they've been so busy with their careers that they've left it too late to conceive naturally. That sort of selfishness is then rewared with this treatment, with 'surplus' embryos being the unfortunate victims.
Thanks for that Delph. It needed saying but if there is an excess of embryos because of this practice, and they can be used to assist the healing of others, isn't it fair and humane that they are? The ethics of not treating someone with Parkinson's Disease with every means available is primative in a supposedly progressive and 'evolving /caring world'.
delph_ambi wrote: I find the concept of deliberately killing an embryo deeply upsetting.
Yes, that is fully understandable Delph.

However, isn't it also upsetting to know that potential treatments exist that can save lives, but are being stopped because some bible-bashing morons think it's anti-god? These same people, who spout an extreme pro-life agenda will and have planted bombs and killed to defend their opinions. That seems a tad convoluted in imho.
delph_ambi wrote: It's true that most embryos, when conceived naturally, do die anyway. Only a few go on to implant and then go to a full term pregnancy. So does it matter?

I'm going to have to sit on the fence for a while over this one.
It's a tough one...
delph_ambi wrote: In the meantime, I think it imperative that the scientists get cracking on adult stem cell research. The huge advantage this has, is that the patient's own stem cells can be used in any treatment, thus getting rid of the danger of rejection. The disadvantage is that embryo stem cells are much easier to multiply, and you would need large numbers for any sort of treatment.
To be honest, I'm going to have to read more on this topic. I really don't know enough.
delph_ambi wrote: It's a difficult one. Adult stem cells yes; embryo ones? Very, very hard question. If science has created these embryos, it has an ethical duty towards them, in my view, that doesn't include either throwing them away or 'using' them in any way other than to implant them in a woman's womb to give them the chance of life.
Isn't there a danger that any stem cells gathered from an adult with an illness like Altzhiemers or Parkinson's Disease will be pre-disposed to generating more infected or unusable cells?

Like I said, I really do need to read more on this topic.

Thank you for your feedback and input here Delph...
Last edited by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh on Mon Oct 30, 2006 12:45 am, edited 2 times in total.
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
Administrator, editor & owner of the Sensitize © online community of forums and domain for artists, e-poets, filmmakers, media/music producers and writers working through here. To buy the Kindle book of Illustrated Poetry, Sensitize © - Volume One / Poems that could be Films if they were Funded by myself with illustrations by Welsh filmmaker and graphic artist; Norris Nuvo click here for N. Ireland and UK sales. If purchasing in the U.S.A. or internationally then please click here.

ASIN B00L1RS0UI

My writing is not covered by Creative Commons policy and may not be republished without permission. All rights reserved. All Sensitize © Arts sponsorship donations and postal inquiries to:

Louis P. Burns
42 Farland Way
DERRY
N. Ireland.
BT48 0RS
Telephone (UK): 028 71219225


Click here to Join Sensitize © Arts via Facebook or to contact the site owner: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh with any forum hosting or site related inquiries.
User avatar
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
site owner, media producer & writer
Posts: 2185
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 7:32 am
Location: Derry, Ireland
Contact:

Post by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh »

Dave. I will take your point about third options on votes into consideration in the future.

For now, I would like to focus on one point you have made:
spacecadet wrote:Should mention that despite being a proddy I'm a very strong Pro-Lifer and all that entails. I only have to look into the eyes of my children to see God.
Is it possible 'God' is simply a feeling? Some deep-rooted awareness that as a species we are aiming to improve upon ourselves?

Perhaps this should be on the Religion - Who Needs It?' thread though...
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
Administrator, editor & owner of the Sensitize © online community of forums and domain for artists, e-poets, filmmakers, media/music producers and writers working through here. To buy the Kindle book of Illustrated Poetry, Sensitize © - Volume One / Poems that could be Films if they were Funded by myself with illustrations by Welsh filmmaker and graphic artist; Norris Nuvo click here for N. Ireland and UK sales. If purchasing in the U.S.A. or internationally then please click here.

ASIN B00L1RS0UI

My writing is not covered by Creative Commons policy and may not be republished without permission. All rights reserved. All Sensitize © Arts sponsorship donations and postal inquiries to:

Louis P. Burns
42 Farland Way
DERRY
N. Ireland.
BT48 0RS
Telephone (UK): 028 71219225


Click here to Join Sensitize © Arts via Facebook or to contact the site owner: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh with any forum hosting or site related inquiries.
spacecadet
visitor

Post by spacecadet »

Lugh wrote:Is it possible 'God' is simply a feeling?
He's the most wonderful feeling that there is, dude. You've just taken a step into a larger universe. How do you feel?
User avatar
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
site owner, media producer & writer
Posts: 2185
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2006 7:32 am
Location: Derry, Ireland
Contact:

Post by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh »

spacecadet wrote:
Lugh wrote:Is it possible 'God' is simply a feeling?
He's the most wonderful feeling that there is, dude. You've just taken a step into a larger universe. How do you feel?
Dave, with the fullest respect in the world mate, and without coming across as an egotistical mouthpiece: I've taken several steps in the multiverse.

My argument has always been with idiotic human beings who have highjacked and used 'God aka Love' to justify division or stamp authority over their fellow human beings or the planet. I'm a deeply spiritual person. I've just never found a faith that preaches real; 'God aka Love'...

Oh, and I would urge you to reconsider your genderisation of 'God aka Love'. We (life) are all the culmination / offspring of both gender identities / procreation. Therefore 'God aka Love' is both female and male. We are all 'God aka Love'.

One of the songs I wrote; Cool, is also seated in this thinking:-
Lugh wrote:COOL.
Lyrics to a song by Louis P. Burns aka Lugh © 1990.
Upstate Renegade Productions © 2000 ~ 2006. All Rights Reserved.


1)
  • Daybreak
    finds me lying
    In the arms of my love.
    She is ev'rything.
    She is how
    my day begins.

    Some people don't understand me.
    Some people say I'm a fool.
    But as long as she loves me,
    that's cool...
2)
  • We walk through the fields
    and feel the love
    of Mother Earth.
    She is ev'rything.
    She is how
    all life begins.

    Some people don't understand us.
    Many people say that we're fools.
    But if a few recognise us,
    that's cool...
  • (Instrumental break)
3)
  • In the evening we lie down
    and sew the seeds of our dreams.
    Our hopes,
    are for the frightened,
    whose day
    still must begin.

    I know you don't understand me.
    I know you think I'm a fool.
    If I've caught your attention,
    that's cool...
Louis P. Burns aka Lugh
Administrator, editor & owner of the Sensitize © online community of forums and domain for artists, e-poets, filmmakers, media/music producers and writers working through here. To buy the Kindle book of Illustrated Poetry, Sensitize © - Volume One / Poems that could be Films if they were Funded by myself with illustrations by Welsh filmmaker and graphic artist; Norris Nuvo click here for N. Ireland and UK sales. If purchasing in the U.S.A. or internationally then please click here.

ASIN B00L1RS0UI

My writing is not covered by Creative Commons policy and may not be republished without permission. All rights reserved. All Sensitize © Arts sponsorship donations and postal inquiries to:

Louis P. Burns
42 Farland Way
DERRY
N. Ireland.
BT48 0RS
Telephone (UK): 028 71219225


Click here to Join Sensitize © Arts via Facebook or to contact the site owner: Louis P. Burns aka Lugh with any forum hosting or site related inquiries.
Post Reply

Return to “Debate & Discussion on Sensitize ©”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests